The American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) is calling on the public, including Medicare patients and their families, to speak out for patient safety and insist that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) preserve Medicare’s longstanding physician supervision requirement for anesthesia care. ASA warns that weakening or eliminating the requirement could leave Medicare patients without immediate access to a physician during a life-threatening emergency.
CMS recently issued a Request for Information (RFI) seeking input on whether to retain or change Medicare’s requirement for physician supervision of certified registered nurse anesthetists (CRNAs).
Seniors spent their working lives paying into Medicare expecting physician care. If CMS eliminates the physician supervision requirement for anesthesia care, they would be victims of a Medicare bait-and-switch. Patient safety is paramount. We are encouraging physicians to share firsthand examples of this lifesaving care to be sure the policy remains in place. But CMS needs to hear from patients and families too, about how important it is to them to have a physician involved in their anesthesia care.”
Jeffrey Mueller, M.D., FASA, ASA President
CMS raised the issue in its Cutting Administrative Requirements for Excellence in Patient Care (CARE) proposed rule as part of a broader effort to reduce regulatory burden in Medicare and Medicaid. The agency has not proposed eliminating or changing the supervision requirement. Its RFI is intended to gather evidence, experience and other information that could inform future policy decisions.
ASA supports cutting unnecessary regulations, but patient safety is not a regulatory burden. Real-life examples from Modesto, California, a state that opted out of Medicare’s physician supervision requirement, illustrate the risks when nurse anesthetists practice without appropriate physician oversight. In 2024, California Department of Public Health reports documented the systematic use of a CRNA-only model of anesthesia services – a violation of California law. The reports documented “serious actual harm,” “serious potential harm,” and “risk of harm, injury and possibly death.”
Independent research shows that physician supervision is key to patient safety, including reducing deaths after complications occur. Further, there is no evidence that removing physician supervision improves access to care. In fact, studies examining Medicare’s opt-out policy allowing states to remove physician supervision of nurse anesthetists have found no meaningful improvement in access to anesthesia care, and eliminating the supervision requirement would provide no direct Medicare budget savings.
Anesthesiologists are medical doctors with advanced education and extensive training. They have the expertise to anticipate and manage how both surgery and anesthesia affect the entire body.
“We identify medical risks before surgery, manage patients’ vital functions during a procedure and respond when complications become life-threatening,” Dr. Mueller said. “For Medicare patients with complex medical conditions, that physician expertise is critical. When an anesthesiologist is missing from the care team, patients lose a vital protection when they are most vulnerable.”
